30+ Secret Santa Gift Ideas for Men and Women: Build a $25 Gift Set

To make browsing easy, each pick is clearly marked For: Women, For: Men, or For: Both. I’ve also gathered the finds in my Amazon storefront, so you can browse and shop your chosen items in one place, saving you time and the headache of searching for everything separately..

Christmas can get expensive fast, and honestly, overspending is not the plan this year.

That’s why I put together this guide to help you build a cute little gift set for $25 or less. Pick a few things you’d like to include, put them together in a gift bag, and keep their combined cost within your budget. A little planning makes the shopping part so much easier.

Whether you’re shopping for a coworker, a classmate, or a student gift exchange, you’ll find 30+ small, useful, and fun picks to mix and match. You only need a few favorites to put your set together—maybe a mini notebook, a lip balm, a handy everyday extra, and something sweet.

The $25 budget is for your whole gift set, so choose a combination that leaves a little room for wrapping and any extra costs.

Beauty and Little Self-Care Extras

1. The Ordinary Travel-Size Gel Moisturizer

For: Both — skincare lovers and frequent travelers.

A little skincare extra for the person who already enjoys their routine. The Ordinary’s Natural Moisturizing Factors + Beta Glucan comes in a lightweight gel formula and a travel-size, 1-ounce tube that fits easily into an overnight bag. 

2. essence Lash Princess Mascara

For: Women — the friend who always wears mascara.

A fresh tube of mascara makes sense for someone whose makeup preferences you know. This black False Lash Effect version pairs nicely with a lip pencil and a claw clip for a small beauty gift. 

3. wet n wild Power Trio Makeup Sponges

For: Women — makeup lovers.

Three makeup sponges to tuck into a little beauty bundle. Add them alongside mascara or a lip product for the friend who enjoys getting ready, whether she’s going out or taking her time with her everyday routine.

4. L.A. COLORS Cocoa Lip Pencil

For: Women — someone who likes a brown lip-liner look.

A cocoa-colored automatic lip pencil is a small addition that can make a makeup gift feel more personal. Choose this for someone who already wears similar shades, then pair it with a lip balm. 

5. e.l.f. Strawberry Squeeze Me Lip Balm

For: Women — the friend with a lip product in every bag.

A strawberry lip balm with a sheer tint for everyday touch-ups. It’s an easy little addition to a gift bag with scrunchies, a mini notebook, or bubble gum. 

6. Hello Kitty Ice Cream Lip Balm

For: Both — Hello Kitty fans.

This Lip Smacker balm brings a playful Hello Kitty touch to the gift. Make it the cute little centerpiece, then add something useful and a sweet treat around it. 

7. Vaseline Rosy Lips Lip Balm

For: Both — anyone who enjoys a little rosy lip care.

A small lip-balm option for a pocket, desk drawer, or everyday bag. The selected listing comes as a two-pack, giving you another choice alongside the fruity and character-themed balms. 

8. eos Strawberry Sorbet Lip Balm

For: Both — fruity lip-balm fans.

For the person who always chooses the strawberry version. This two-pack makes a sweet little addition to a bundle with a notebook, hair accessory, or their favorite gum. 

9. NIVEA Mini Creme

For: Both — the friend who keeps everyday essentials close.

A small, 1-ounce cream for someone who already likes NIVEA. Pair it with a lip balm and a little treat for a practical gift they can keep in their bag or desk drawer. 

Hair Accessories, Cozy Finds, and Gym-Bag Extras

10. Wet Brush Mini Detangler in Ice Cream

For: Both — anyone who likes keeping a brush in their bag.

The Ice Cream design gives this mini travel brush a playful touch. Its compact size makes it a useful pick for an overnight bag, gym bag, or the friend who is always getting ready somewhere other than home.

11. Goody Claw Clips

For: Both — anyone with hair long enough to clip up.

For quick updos, getting ready, and putting their hair back after a long day. This two-piece set includes one black and one brown medium claw clip, so the colors are easy to work into an everyday routine.

12. Kitsch Spiral Hair Ties in Brunette

For: Both — ponytail and bun people.

A four-pack of brown spiral hair ties for the person who can never find one when they need it. Add them to a little bag with the mini hairbrush or a lip balm. 

13. Goody Satin Scrunchies

For: Women — the friend who loves an easy hair-up moment.

A set of satin scrunchies in neutral tones makes a useful little hair gift. They fit naturally into a bundle with lip balm, a mini brush, or a small cream. 

14. Silver Rhinestone Hair Barrettes

For: Women — the friend who loves a little sparkle.

These two KANPRINCESS silver rhinestone barrettes can dress up a simple hairstyle for dinner, a party, or a holiday get-together. A cute pick for someone who enjoys adding one sparkly detail before heading out.

15. Waffle-Knit Scarf

For: Both — anyone who loves getting bundled up.

A textured scarf for chilly mornings, coffee runs, and winter walks. Choose a color that works with their usual coat, and let this be the main gift if its current price fits your budget.

16. Nike Swoosh Classic Headband

For: Both — gym, running, and basketball fans.

A sporty little extra for the person who always has a workout planned. The classic Swoosh and absorbent terry-cloth fabric make it an easy addition to their gym bag.

Cute Desk, Stationery, and Book-Lover Gifts

17. AZUREAL Green Weekly Planner Pad

For: Both — list-makers and busy coworkers.

For the person who likes seeing their whole week in one place. This green desk planner has 52 tear-off sheets for tasks, reminders, appointments, and all the little things they’re trying to keep track of.

18. Mini Spiral Notebooks

For: Both — people with ideas at inconvenient times.

Little notebooks for reminders, shopping lists, and thoughts they want to save before they disappear. These pocket-size notebooks come in a six-pack, so you can tuck one into the gift while counting the full pack cost in your shopping budget. 

19. Taja Pink Spiral Journal

For: Both — stationery lovers who enjoy a pink notebook.

A fresh notebook has its own little appeal. This pink hardcover journal has ruled pages for plans, notes, and everyday writing, making it a nice main pick for someone who still prefers putting pen to paper.

20. Taja Pastel Gel Pens

For: Both — the friend who gets excited about stationery.

Pastel-colored pens for making everyday lists feel a little cuter. They write in black ink and come in a six-piece set, so they pair easily with either notebook option.

21. Mr. Pen Pastel Highlighters

For: Both — planners, students, and journal lovers.

For the person whose notes have a color system. This six-pack of pastel highlighters would work well with a weekly planner, notebook, or a little candy tucked into the gift bag. 

22. Black Cat Sticky Notes

For: Both — cat people and desk-supply collectors.

Little black cats make a to-do list more fun to look at. This set includes six pads, giving your coworker or stationery-loving friend plenty of space for reminders and quick notes.

23. Venus Flytrap Bookmarks

For: Both — book lovers and plant people.

Tiny Venus flytraps keeping their place in a book? Very cute. Genuine Fred’s Prey on Words bookmarks come as a pair of soft silicone page markers, making them a playful pick for someone who loves both books and plants. 

24. Clear Business Card Holder

For: Both — small-business owners and office friends.

For the friend who just launched something of their own. This clear HSYMQ card holder gives their business cards a neat little spot on a desk or counter, and a handwritten “proud of you” note would make it more personal.

Small Home Gifts with a Personal Touch

25. HouseGem Mug and Candle Warmer Plate

For: Both — coffee, tea, and cozy-desk people.

For the person who keeps abandoning their coffee halfway through the morning. This black warming plate is designed for compatible flat-bottomed mugs and candle jars. Treat it as a main gift and check the current offer before choosing the extras. 

26. Walnut-Base 4 × 6 Picture Frame

For: Both — anyone who loves displaying favorite photos.

A sweet little spot for a favorite photo. This horizontal 4 × 6-inch frame has a walnut wood base and clear acrylic covers, making it a cute addition to a desk or bedside table. Pair it with a small notebook and a sweet treat for an easy little gift set.

27. Amber Bubble-Glass Holder

For: Both — anyone who loves cute desk or home accessories.

A cute little home for the things that always end up scattered around. This amber bubble-glass holder can keep pens, makeup brushes, or jewelry together on a desk or vanity. Pair it with pastel pens or a small accessory from this list for an easy little gift set.

Playful Little Extras and Sweet Treats

28. Mini Puzzle Cube Keychain

For: Both — puzzle lovers.

A tiny 3 × 3 cube that clips onto their keys or bag. This LiangCuber keychain is a fun little extra for the person who always wants something to figure out.

29. Black Phoenix Chopsticks with a Case

For: Both — noodle and sushi fans.

Reusable metal chopsticks with their own carrying case for lunch bags and noodle nights. The black Phoenix design gives an everyday utensil a little personality.

30. Klein Tools Bottle Opener

For: Men — the DIY fan or tool collector.

A bottle opener with the look of a proper tool and a chunky black-and-yellow handle. It’s a useful little gadget to pair with a favorite snack or a bottled drink. 

31. Bicycle Five-Dice Set

For: Both — game-night people.

Five classic six-sided dice for the friend who is always suggesting another round. Add a snack and a handwritten game-night invitation to make this small gift feel more personal.

32. Axolotl Squishy Toy

For: Both — anyone who loves cute desk toys.

A little slow-rise axolotl to squeeze between tasks and keep beside their keyboard. Choose this for the friend who would absolutely give their desk toy a name.

33. Trident Bubble Gum

For: Both — bubble-gum fans.

Sometimes the finishing touch is as simple as their favorite gum. This bubblegum-flavored option comes in a three-pack and fits easily into a little gift bag with stationery, beauty picks, or everyday essentials. 

34. HARIBO Goldbears

For: Both — gummy-candy lovers.

A sweet little extra for the person who always reaches for gummy bears. Add the bag alongside their main gift, or choose it as the treat in a notebook-and-pen bundle.

35. Reusable Metal Straw Set

For: Both — tumbler lovers and iced-coffee fans.

For the person whose tumbler goes everywhere with them. This reusable metal straw set is designed for 20- and 30-ounce tumblers and includes two cleaning brushes. Pair it with bubble gum and another small everyday extra to build their gift set.